igration, a universal human phenomenon, has been reframed in political discourse as a polarizing issue; manipulated by populist leaders and far–right movements to amplify fear, bolster nationalism, and foster division. Across Europe, North America, and beyond, migration dominates electoral debates, reflecting anxieties about security, economic volatility, demographic change, cultural identity, and crime.
State fragility and violent conflict, often shaped by shortsighted foreign interventions in Afghanistan, Ukraine, Venezuela, and other regions, remain key drivers of migration. By mid–2024, the global number of forcibly displaced people rose to 122.6 million, prompting stricter measures in destination countries.
Destination countries such as Finland and Poland have expanded border walls, while nations like Algeria, Türkiye, and Pakistan implemented large–scale expulsions. In the U.S., President Donald Trump’s declaration of a "national emergency" at the southern border signals a similar approach, with plans to revive policies such as “Remain in Mexico,” which have exposed asylum seekers to violence and have strained neighboring countries’ resources. The EU’s new Migration Pact, emphasizing externalized asylum procedures through third–country “return hubs,” also faces logistical and ethical challenges. Meanwhile, unexpected geopolitical developments, such as the fall of Bashar al–Assad, must be carefully managed within a volatile migration context to ensure durable returns aligned with Syria’s reconstruction efforts.
Quick fixes like deportation obscure migration’s complexities. Nearly 40% of the 11.2 million undocumented migrants in the U.S. have legal authorization to live or work, and many are deeply integrated into their communities. Deportations destabilize origin countries, eroding remittance flows and reinforcing cycles of poverty and violence. Historical examples, such as Canada’s deportations during the Great Depression and Uganda’s expulsion of Asian entrepreneurs, highlight the economic damage such policies can inflict.
Conversely, migration offers significant opportunities. Aging populations in wealthy nations increasingly rely on migrants to address labor shortages. Migrants already play vital roles in healthcare and construction across the U.S., Europe, and the UK. Some demographers even foresee competition between nations to attract a shrinking pool of young migrants.
To unlock migration’s potential, policymakers must adopt rights–based, evidence–driven, and context–appropriate approaches that balance immediate needs with long–term planning. Integration strategies like Germany’s vocational training programs and careful investments in education, green industries, and gender equity in origin countries can address the drivers of involuntary displacement while benefiting host nations. Recognizing migration as a multifaceted global phenomenon rather than a crisis in isolation is critical to creating solutions that foster resilience and shared prosperity.
a global affairs media network
A path forward amid divisive, fear–ridden migration debate
Photo by Lucas de Moura on Unsplash
February 18, 2025
Migration’s politicization has been manipulated by populist leaders and far–right movements. But while widespread migration brings challenges, it also offers significant opportunities if we approach in ways that are evidence–driven, rights–based, context–appropriate, writes Dr. Marissa Quie.
M
igration, a universal human phenomenon, has been reframed in political discourse as a polarizing issue; manipulated by populist leaders and far–right movements to amplify fear, bolster nationalism, and foster division. Across Europe, North America, and beyond, migration dominates electoral debates, reflecting anxieties about security, economic volatility, demographic change, cultural identity, and crime.
State fragility and violent conflict, often shaped by shortsighted foreign interventions in Afghanistan, Ukraine, Venezuela, and other regions, remain key drivers of migration. By mid–2024, the global number of forcibly displaced people rose to 122.6 million, prompting stricter measures in destination countries.
Destination countries such as Finland and Poland have expanded border walls, while nations like Algeria, Türkiye, and Pakistan implemented large–scale expulsions. In the U.S., President Donald Trump’s declaration of a "national emergency" at the southern border signals a similar approach, with plans to revive policies such as “Remain in Mexico,” which have exposed asylum seekers to violence and have strained neighboring countries’ resources. The EU’s new Migration Pact, emphasizing externalized asylum procedures through third–country “return hubs,” also faces logistical and ethical challenges. Meanwhile, unexpected geopolitical developments, such as the fall of Bashar al–Assad, must be carefully managed within a volatile migration context to ensure durable returns aligned with Syria’s reconstruction efforts.
Quick fixes like deportation obscure migration’s complexities. Nearly 40% of the 11.2 million undocumented migrants in the U.S. have legal authorization to live or work, and many are deeply integrated into their communities. Deportations destabilize origin countries, eroding remittance flows and reinforcing cycles of poverty and violence. Historical examples, such as Canada’s deportations during the Great Depression and Uganda’s expulsion of Asian entrepreneurs, highlight the economic damage such policies can inflict.
Conversely, migration offers significant opportunities. Aging populations in wealthy nations increasingly rely on migrants to address labor shortages. Migrants already play vital roles in healthcare and construction across the U.S., Europe, and the UK. Some demographers even foresee competition between nations to attract a shrinking pool of young migrants.
To unlock migration’s potential, policymakers must adopt rights–based, evidence–driven, and context–appropriate approaches that balance immediate needs with long–term planning. Integration strategies like Germany’s vocational training programs and careful investments in education, green industries, and gender equity in origin countries can address the drivers of involuntary displacement while benefiting host nations. Recognizing migration as a multifaceted global phenomenon rather than a crisis in isolation is critical to creating solutions that foster resilience and shared prosperity.
